Big Questons in History.

By Harriet Swain

Printed: 2005

Publisher: Jonathan Cape. London

Edition: First edition

Dimensions 15 × 23 × 3 cm

Language: English

Size (cminches): 15 x 23 x 3

Buy Now

Item information


In the original dustsheet. Black cloth binding with gilt title on the spine.

  • F.B.A. provides an in-depth photographic presentation of this item to stimulate your feeling and touch. More traditional book descriptions are immediately available.

A book that deserves to be read!

Drawing on examples ranging from ancient Greece to Tony Blair’s Britain, leading historical thinkers address 20 of the really big questions that have been asked over the centuries about the course of human events. Each essay is put into context by a more general commentary that discusses the differing views of other leading thinkers, today and in the past. The result is a stimulating ride over continents and across centuries in search of answers that are sometimes surprising, often controversial, and all of great relevance to how we live today.

Includes writing by: Richard. J. Evans, Ian Kershaw, Vernon Bogdanor, Fred Halliday, Thomas Palaima, Jeremy Black, Colin Renfrew, Anthony Pagden, Lisa Jardine, Sheila Rowbotham, Joanna Bourke, Benjamin Barber, Felipe Fernández-Armesto and others.


Big Questions In History was a most worthwhile read. It deals with twenty major themes, including:

* What is history?

* What makes a great leader?

* Why do revolutions happen?

* How does private life affect public life?

* Why do religious and spiritual movements grow?

* Can history have an end?

Each theme is introduced by a leading authority in the field, and this is followed by a commentary by freelance writers — contributions which are equally interesting and profound. Each contribution is about five pages long — dealing with the issues in an approachable way, and opening up intelligent discussion, with illuminating examples from history. As a mere glimpse at the content of the book, three subjects follow — the first two being chapter themes, and the third being an underlying theme of the book.

Linda Woodhead deals with the question as to why religious and spiritual movements grow. She proposes the following. Religion is likely to flourish in alliance with worldly power — or, on the other hand, in DEFIANCE of earthly power — while spirituality (personal religion) is likely to flourish in the wake of the same. In this regard, she comments, “Islam finds itself in the sweet spot where the two most propitious conditions for religious growth coincide.” On the other hand, Stephen Phillips proposes that those Christian Churches which are seeing the strongest growth today “feature a less intellectually rarefied, omniscient, interventionist God”, which further appeals to “the poor and downtrodden”.

The chapter which came as the greatest surprise to me was, What makes a great leader? Brendan Simms and Phil Baty describe characteristics which at first seem quite counter-intuitive. Leadership, firstly, should be unplanned — a major example being Otto von Bismarck, who began as “a defender of a narrow conservative Prussian aristocratic interest”, yet became the architect of German unification. Simms quotes Oliver Cromwell: “He goeth furthest who knows not where he is going.” Secondly, great leaders tended to surround themselves with “enemies”. Baty refers to Margaret Thatcher as an example, for “her willingness to keep critics”.

As for the persons considered to have had the greatest impact on our modern understanding of history, Niccolo Machiavelli and Karl Marx rank high on the list. Machiavelli was a famous-notorious political philosopher, and a great realist and pragmatist. By and large, it would seem to be his realist approach to history that gives him his present appeal. Ideology is out, realism is in. Marx, on the other hand, has pride of place, not for his view of historical progress (which the book generally regards as a “blithe” attitude), but for the view that history is shaped by broad movements of men and women. Before Marx, history tended to be limited to “great men”.

This book was a most worthwhile read, and gave one a good feel for “the state of history” today. It includes useful lists for further reading, and a comprehensive index.

Want to know more about this item?

We are happy to answer any questions you may have about this item. In addition, it is also possible to request more photographs if there is something specific you want illustrated.
Ask a question

Share this Page with a friend